A recent viral statement by fitness coach Dan Go has set the internet fitness world alight, challenging the status of the humble burpee as a go-to move for weight loss and total body fitness. Describing it as “the worst exercise on the planet,” Dan Go’s remarks have prompted vigorous debate among experts, trainers, and everyday exercisers alike. While the burpee’s challenging, full-body movement has made it a staple in HIIT (High Intensity Interval Training) classes and boot camps—from Bangkok gyms to schools nationwide—Go’s critique raises essential questions about which exercises truly support healthy, sustainable weight loss and injury prevention.
For many Thai readers familiar with the burpee’s punishing reputation—think โรงยิม (fitness centers) or even PE classes across the country—the controversy is immediately relatable. The exercise, originally invented by physiologist Royal H. Burpee in the 1930s as a simple fitness test, involves a mix of squats, planks, push-ups, and jumps, completed in rapid sequence. Over the decades, it has gained a fearsome reputation: hailed for its ability to torch calories but loathed for the toll it can take on the joints, especially in populations new to fitness or those with underlying health conditionsWikipedia.
Dan Go, followed by hundreds of thousands on social media, minced no words in his assessment. “You’re cramming a chaotic jumble of movements together and calling it a workout,” he wrote, likening the burpee to “a chaotic mess disguised as a workout.” Instead of delivering efficient results, Go argues that burpees combine risky, high-impact moves that can compromise form, multiply injury risk, and demoralize those just starting their fitness journeyHindustan Times.
This criticism is not merely a fad or isolated opinion. According to recent expert reviews, while the burpee undoubtedly challenges the cardiovascular and muscular systems, it can also overstress the knees, wrists, and lower back, particularly when done quickly or in high volumes. A summary of scientific studies by health writer Ravi Davda, CPT, for Garage Gym Reviews, highlights that burpee-heavy HIIT regimens can correlate with higher rates of knee and ankle sprains and strains among both seasoned athletes and beginners alikeGarage Gym Reviews. A 2019 study in the Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness (“Injuries sustained during high intensity interval training: are modern fitness trends contributing to increased injury rates?”) backs this up, noting a rise in exercise-related injuries among those performing complex, high-impact movements like the burpee.
So, what is a more intelligent route to weight loss and fitness? For Dan Go and a growing contingent of coaches, the solution lies in smarter, more accessible exercises that minimize risk while maximizing results. Go and other experts recommend moves such as squats, push-ups (with modified variations), kettlebell swings, mountain climbers, and jumping jacks. These alternatives are easier to learn, place less stress on joints, and can be adapted for all fitness levels. Notably, Thai trainers and online wellness communities—such as the fast-growing ฟิตเนสไทย (Fitnet Thai) platform—have echoed Go’s views, emphasizing the importance of tailoring exercise intensity to individual ability and age.
Ravi Davda’s comprehensive list of 12 “burpee alternatives”—including medicine ball slams, plank jacks, dumbbell thrusters, inchworm push-ups, and bear crawls—provides a roadmap for those seeking the cardiovascular and muscular benefits of burpees with fewer risks. Each alternative can be scaled up or down in difficulty, ensuring that beginners and seasoned fitness enthusiasts alike find suitable options. For instance, the plank jack targets core and glutes with a lower impact, while medicine ball slams deliver a satisfying, whole-body workout without the complex, repeated transitions from floor to standing that make burpees so taxingGarage Gym Reviews.
But why do burpees remain so stubbornly popular, despite these criticisms? Partly, their reputation for “no equipment, big results” fits the needs of Bangkok’s cramped condos and rural Thai homes where equipment may be scarce, but drive and determination are plentiful. Furthermore, Thai fitness culture’s embrace of high-intensity, “no pain, no gain” approaches—mirrored in the popularity of Muay Thai circuits and interval classes—makes the simple, tough burpee a natural fit.
Yet, as health awareness spreads and injury prevention becomes a bigger concern—especially among Thailand’s rapidly aging population and younger urbanites balancing intense work lives—the conversation is shifting. Experts urge programs that build strength, mobility, and cardiovascular health gradually. As Dr. Somsak Chalitaporn, a Thai sports medicine physician, noted in a 2024 interview: “We must look beyond the one-size-fits-all approach. Safe exercise is sustainable exercise. เพิ่มความแข็งแรง (strength gains) and ลดน้ำหนัก (weight loss) should not come at the price of chronic pain or discouragement.” While burpees may have a place for well-conditioned athletes, the consensus is shifting toward exercises with broader accessibility and lower risk.
In Thai schools, too, PE curriculums are being re-examined. Educators are advised to include a variety of safe, progressive movements rather than relying on “punishment” sets of burpees for discipline or motivation—a practice still common in some programs but now under scrutiny as health literacy improves.
Looking forward, the burpee debate symbolizes a larger shift toward evidence-based, individualized fitness, both in Thailand and globally. In line with global trends—such as those highlighted in the New York Times’ 2024 review of “most hated exercises”NYT—a balance of enjoyment, safety, and effectiveness is now the gold standard. “Find movement that you enjoy, that you can sustain for years—not just weeks,” advises Coach Natty, a well-known Thai fitness educator, in her popular YouTube channel.
For Thai readers considering their own fitness journeys, the actionable advice is clear:
- Choose exercises that suit your current level and don’t feel painful or overly punitive.
- Seek variety—mix strength, cardio, and flexibility moves for well-rounded fitness.
- If you love burpees, do them safely and with good form, possibly at a lower intensity.
- Don’t be afraid to substitute: mountain climbers, jump squats, or kettlebell swings can offer similar calorie-burning benefits with less risk.
- Consult fitness professionals or physical therapists if you have underlying health concerns or past injuries.
Above all, remember: สุขภาพดีไม่มีขาย (good health can’t be bought)—it must be earned with patience, care, and the right moves for your body. For those seeking weight loss or general fitness, informed choice trumps fitness trends, every time.
Sources: