A major hospital network in New York’s Hudson Valley has agreed to overhaul its mental health services amid findings of serious care lapses during a state investigation—a move being closely watched by healthcare advocates internationally, including in Thailand, as systems globally grapple with post-pandemic gaps in psychiatric care (Gothamist). The action underscores both ongoing struggles in mental healthcare access and increasing government pressure for reform in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic’s disruptions.
WMCHealth, which operates nine hospitals throughout the Hudson Valley, has accepted a legally binding settlement requiring the restoration of psychiatric beds shuttered during the pandemic and the enhancement of protocols for emergency mental health care. HealthAlliance Hospital in Kingston, part of the WMCHealth system, already reopened 20 psychiatric beds in December 2024 in response to the investigation. Additionally, WMCHealth has committed to constructing a new 20-bed psychiatric unit at MidHudson Regional Hospital in Poughkeepsie, as announced by New York Attorney General Letitia James.
For Thai readers, this news carries particular relevance as Thailand also saw significant digital and in-person psychiatric service disruptions during the pandemic. In northern Thai provinces like Chiang Mai and Lampang, similar hospital “surge capacity” orders meant psychiatric patients sometimes faced long waits or were compelled to travel to Bangkok for urgent care—a challenge also experienced by Hudson Valley residents (Bangkok Post; WHO Thailand). The New York case highlights how government oversight and community pressure can drive urgently needed change.
The state’s investigation, launched in 2022, was prompted by testimonies from community members and advocates following the closure of a key 40-bed psychiatric unit at HealthAlliance Hospital. The probe found that, in several instances, WMCHealth hospitals discharged or allowed suicidal or acutely ill psychiatric patients to leave before being properly stabilized, resulting in what the attorney general described as “preventable tragedies.” Incomplete or inaccurate medical documentation further complicated patient care and care transitions—a finding echoed in Thai hospital audits post-pandemic (Gothamist).
Attorney General Letitia James emphasized the gravity of these failings, stating, “Mental health care is medical care, and mental health crises must be treated as the emergencies they are…My office will continue to fight to ensure all New Yorkers have access to quality, compassionate emergency mental health care.” Experts in psychiatric medicine echoed these sentiments. Dr. Paul S. Appelbaum, professor of psychiatry at Columbia University, commented separately, “Regulatory scrutiny is crucial to ensure that psychiatric patients are not left behind, particularly in times of system-wide stress, such as a pandemic” (Columbia Psychiatry).
Under the terms of the agreement, WMCHealth will pay US$400,000 in penalties and fees and faces further fines of $10,000 per violation if it fails to comply with the settlement. The reforms go beyond physical capacity: WMCHealth is required to overhaul its discharge planning and guidelines on the use of physical restraints, especially with children—a measure praised by patient advocates for respecting patient dignity and safety.
Andrew LaGuardia, spokesperson for WMCHealth, maintained that his network is the largest inpatient psychiatric provider in the Hudson Valley and faces complex challenges: “Our goal is always to provide the highest quality care for every patient and take immediate action to address any situation where our standard of care has not been met,” he said.
Historically, psychiatric healthcare in the United States, much like in Thailand, has suffered systemic underfunding and stigma, often exacerbated by crises. In New York, the pandemic led then-Governor Andrew Cuomo to order psychiatric wards converted for COVID “surge capacity,” a change that was meant to be temporary but has lasted for years at many institutions. Efforts by Governor Kathy Hochul to restore pre-pandemic psychiatric capacity have included threatened fines for hospitals failing to comply, reflecting a more assertive stance from state government than seen in previous decades.
The settlement marks a novel use of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), a federal law traditionally used to require hospitals to treat all medical emergencies regardless of a patient’s ability to pay. This is believed to be the first time a state has invoked EMTALA for behavioral health care, setting a potential precedent for similar interventions nationwide and abroad.
For Thailand, this case may inspire policymakers and advocates seeking to strengthen mental health protections. Recent calls from Thai psychiatrists to update the Mental Health Act and ensure community-based psychiatric care are in line with international best practices. There remains a pressing need for increased support and oversight—particularly as new data suggest mental health crises, including suicide rates, have risen in post-pandemic Thailand and across ASEAN (Thai PBS; UNICEF Thailand).
As the world slowly emerges from the acute phase of COVID-19, experts predict a sustained mental health “echo pandemic,” with vulnerable groups—such as youth, the elderly, and frontline workers—at increased risk for untreated psychiatric illnesses. For hospitals, the lesson from WMCHealth is clear: temporary lapses in psychiatric services can turn catastrophic if left unaddressed.
Thai readers are encouraged to push for greater community engagement and transparency in mental health provision. Monitoring hospital compliance, demanding proper psychiatric bed quotas, and advocating for patient rights—especially for marginalized and rural populations—are essential. In everyday life, Thais can contribute by reducing stigma, promoting peer support, and familiarizing themselves with available crisis resources, such as the Department of Mental Health’s 1323 hotline.
The WMCHealth case reminds us that policy reforms do matter and that collective advocacy—from patients and families to watchdog agencies—can reshape mental health systems for the better.
For further reading and resources: