In the ever-evolving world of romance, playing “hard-to-get” remains one of the most debated dating strategies. A new empirical review, highlighted in a recent article by Psychology Today, dives deep into decades of research to determine whether creating an air of mystery and unavailability truly makes someone more attractive—or whether transparency and directness, particularly valued in today’s digital age, have rendered the tactic obsolete.
For Thai readers navigating both traditional values and modern dating trends, this discussion is highly relevant. The strategy of playing hard-to-get, which involves intentionally delaying responses, keeping intentions ambiguous, or sporadically signaling romantic interest, is familiar across cultures. In the Thai context, social etiquette often encourages subtlety and restraint in early stages of courtship, making it important to examine if scientific evidence supports, or challenges, these ingrained behaviors.
The latest review, published in the Journal of Sex Research, analyzed 18 studies exploring the effectiveness of playing hard-to-get in dating scenarios. As summarized by Psychology Today, these studies collectively suggest a nuanced picture: some degree of playing hard-to-get can indeed increase attraction—particularly when a person’s level of interest remains moderately ambiguous. One experiment, for instance, found that heterosexual women were more attracted to men when their feelings about the women were uncertain, as opposed to being either clearly enthusiastic or only moderately interested. Psychologists speculate that this uncertainty triggers a cognitive “loop” where people spend more time thinking about the other person, driven by the desire to resolve the ambiguity (Psychology Today).
Another notable finding relates to “selective hard-to-get” behavior: where someone is open and available to a specific person but generally elusive to others. Studies showed that individuals on the receiving end of this selectiveness experienced increased self-esteem—being chosen as a special exception appeared to heighten their attraction and sense of value. This points to a psychological mechanism at play: the combination of exclusivity and challenge can be particularly alluring.
However, the science also cautions against overusing this tactic. If someone is perceived as extremely hard-to-get, they may come across as disinterested or arrogant, causing potential partners to lose interest altogether. Conversely, appearing too eager or easily available may reduce perceived value, possibly because exclusivity and discernment are attractive qualities. These findings reflect a “Goldilocks principle”—moderation is key. Too much distance or over-availability risks undermining initial attraction.
Expert commentary from the review—while not tied to individual names—underscores this balance. One research team observed, “playing hard-to-get may be effective in inducing lure by creating confusion or intrigue that leads to rumination about the player,” but also confirmed that cultural shifts towards valuing direct communication mean the strategy’s effectiveness may be shrinking, especially among those who prefer clarity in relationships (Journal of Sex Research).
For Thailand, these conclusions offer both validation and a cautionary note. Flirting practices such as “ngai jai” (playing coy or feigning indifference) have long been woven into the social fabric, celebrated in Thai television and pop culture. Yet, young Thais increasingly interact through dating apps and social media, where delayed responses or mixed signals can quickly be misconstrued as disinterest. The rise of instant communication may, as some international studies suggest, diminish the allure of playing hard-to-get (Psychology Today).
International research also reveals that individual differences play a critical role. For example, some people are more attracted to clear, transparent partners who openly express their interest. For these individuals—regardless of cultural background—playing hard-to-get may actually backfire, leading them to seek more straightforward relationships. This aligns with ongoing trends in Thai society towards valuing authenticity and open communication, influenced both by global norms and domestic campaigns promoting healthy relationships (Bangkok Post).
While much of the research relies on hypothetical scenarios and controlled experiments, and may not fully capture the complexity of real-life interactions, these studies nonetheless offer useful insights. Some researchers have tried speed-dating formats to mimic reality, but even these are limited in simulating long-term romantic dynamics.
Looking ahead, cultural evolution is likely to further reshape dating norms in Thailand and worldwide. With greater acceptance of varied relationship models, growing emphasis on mental health, and the influence of global pop culture, the old rules—like playing hard-to-get—may need revision or adaptation. Still, core psychological mechanisms such as the intrigue of selective interest and the motivation to resolve uncertainty are likely to remain potent, albeit expressed in different ways.
For Thai readers considering the use of this dating strategy, the takeaway is clear: moderation counts. Expressing some interest while maintaining an element of mystery can foster attraction, but being overly ambiguous or detached risks losing potential partners. Most importantly, be mindful of individual and cultural differences—some people appreciate a little chase, while others prefer directness. In the Thai context, blending traditional relational nuances with contemporary expectations for clarity promises the highest chance of romantic success.
For those seeking practical advice:
- Use the “just right” approach—show enough interest to make your intentions known, but leave some things to the imagination.
- If interacting online or via apps, be especially careful that delays or mixed signals are not interpreted as apathy.
- Recognize and respect differences in communication style—if your partner prefers openness, prioritize directness over playing hard-to-get.
- Reflect on your own motivations: are you using this strategy to create healthy excitement, or as a shield against vulnerability?
Ultimately, successful relationships—whether sparked with a bit of mystery or built on immediate honesty—depend on mutual respect, communication, and understanding. Staying flexible and attuned to both tradition and change will help Thais navigate the complex landscape of modern romance.