#IndividualizedFitness

A new wave of fitness trends has taken social media by storm, with a viral sound bite declaring that every woman should be able to do 11 push-ups—a claim sparking debate among experts and everyday people alike. The prescription, delivered by a well-known orthopedic surgeon on a prominent self-help podcast, has led thousands to post their attempts online and question the implications of adopting such “one-size-fits-all” health guidance. In a fitness culture increasingly shaped by social media and so-called “wellness bros,” the debate points to larger questions about evidence-based exercise targets, inclusivity, and the real meaning of health and performance.

A viral push-up challenge has reignited debate over universal fitness advice as health influencers and social media personalities continue to promote “one-size-fits-all” approaches that oversimplify individual needs. The latest flashpoint centers on an 11 push-ups benchmark for women—an arbitrary fitness goal that has gained traction across platforms like TikTok but is raising concerns among exercise scientists and registered dietitians.

Recently, an orthopedic surgeon and prominent health influencer appeared on a well-known self-help podcast, declaring that every woman should be able to perform 11 standard push-ups (not the so-called “girl push-ups” on knees). The pronouncement sparked a wave of online responses, with women documenting either their success in completing the challenge or their struggles to meet the standard. The viral moment highlights society’s fascination with clear, quantifiable measures of health—even when such goals lack personal nuance or scientific flexibility (Vox).